Key points from the evidence | Right Decisions

Right Decisions
Scottish Health Technologies Group (SHTG)
Back
Placental growth factor (PlGF)-based testing to help diagnose suspected preterm pre-eclampsia [In development]
Key points from the evidence

Announcements and latest updates

Welcome to the Right Decision Service (RDS) newsletter for August 2024.

Contingency planning for RDS outages

Following the recent RDS outages, Tactuum and the RDS team have been reviewing the learning from these incidents. We are committed to doing all we can to ensure a positive outcome by strengthening the RDS to make it fully robust and clinically resilient for the future.

We would like to invite you to a webinar on 26^th September 3-4 pm on national and local contingency planning for future RDS outages. Tactuum and the RDS team will speak about our business continuity plans and the national contingency arrangements we are putting in place. This will also be a space to share local contingency plans, ideas and existing good practice. We would also like to gather your views on who we should send communications to in the event of future outages.

I have sent a meeting request for this date to all editors – please accept or decline to indicate attendance, and please forward on to relevant contacts. You can also contact Olivia.graham@nhs.scot directly to register your interest in participating.

2.National IV fluid prescribing calculator

This UK CA marked calculator is now live at https://righdecisions.scot.nhs.uk/ivfluids . It has been developed by a multiprofessional steering group of leads in IV fluids management, as part of the wider Modernising Patient Pathways Programme within the Centre for Sustainable Delivery. It aims to address a known cause of clinical error in hospital settings, and we hope it will be especially useful to the new junior doctors who started in August.

Please do spread the word about this new calculator and get in touch with any questions.

New toolkits

The following toolkits are now live;

Gender identity healthcare: adults and young people standards. (https://rightdecisions.scot.nhs.uk/genderidentity ) Note that this toolkit includes self-evaluation forms for each standard. A Scottish Government launch of these standards, together with the toolkit and NES educational resources, is planned for 3^rd September.
Care Inspectorate staffing method framework.
Vascular surgery pathways from the Modernising Patient Pathways Programme within the Centre for Sustainable Healthcare Delivery.

Updated guidance on current and future Medical Device Regulations

We have updated and simplified this guidance within our standard operating procedures. We have clarified the guidance on how to determine whether an RDS tool is a medical device, and have provided an interactive powerpoint slideset to steer you through the process.

Guide to six stages of RDS toolkit development

We have developed a guide to support editors and toolkit leads through the process of scoping, designing, delivering, quality assuring and implementing a new RDS toolkit. We hope this will help in project planning and in building shared understanding of responsibilities throughout the full development process. The guide emphasises that the project does not end with launch of the new toolkit. Implementation, communication and evaluation are ongoing activities throughout the lifetime of the toolkit.

Training sessions for new editors (also serve as refresher sessions for existing editors) will take place on the following dates:

Thursday 5 September 1-2 pm
Wednesday 24 September 4-5 pm
Friday 27 September 12-1 pm

To book a place, please contact Olivia.graham@nhs.scot, providing your name, organisation, job role, and level of experience with RDS editing (none, a little, moderate, extensive.)

7 Evaluation projects

Dr Stephen Biggart from NHS Lothian has kindly shared with us the results of a recent survey of use of the Edinburgh Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh Anaesthesia toolkit. This shows that the majority of consultants are using it weekly or monthly, mainly to access clinical protocols, with a secondary purpose being education and training purposes. They tend to find information by navigating by specialty rather than keyword searching, and had some useful recommendations for future development, such as access to quick reference guidance.

We’d really appreciate you sharing any other local evaluations of RDS in this way – it all helps to build the evidence base for impact.

If you have any questions about the content of this newsletter, please contact his.decisionsupport@nhs.scot If you would prefer not to receive future newsletters, please email Olivia.graham@nhs.scot and ask to be removed from the circulation list.

With kind regards

Right Decision Service team

Healthcare Improvement Scotland

NICE guidance on PlGF-based testing to help diagnose suspected preterm pre-eclampsia (published in July 2022) has been adapted for NHSScotland. The NICE guidance was appraised, and no barriers to use relating to relevance, reliability and transferability of the evidence were identified.

Based on a review of the evidence, in terms of clinical effectiveness, NICE concluded that the use of PlGF-based tests to rule in and rule out preterm pre-eclampsia have the potential to reduce time to diagnosis, reduce maternal adverse outcomes, and improve decisions about care.
The economic evaluation by NICE reported that PlGF-based tests are cost effective, providing more quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) at lower costs when compared with standard assessment. This is achieved through a reduction in the resource impact of false negative diagnoses, and by the avoidance of unnecessary hospital admissions in people who can be safely managed out of hospital. PlGF-based tests remained cost effective in all the modelled scenarios. The extent of cost savings and improvement to outcomes varied depending on the evidence used to model the effectiveness of standard assessment and how test results affect clinical decision making.
NICE recommends four PlGF-based tests. The decision on tests to use in NHSScotland should be made locally within each health board. This will depend on factors such as the existing analysers, geography and cost. NICE do not recommend any test over another.
The diagnosis of pre-eclampsia may be made based on the onset of new significant sustained hypertension and proteinuria alone. PlGF-based testing is likely to be most useful in pregnant people when the diagnosis of preterm pre-eclampsia is less clear.