Introduction
It is important to discuss the topic of fertility with pre-menopausal women at the time of diagnosis, discussing their wishes for a family and mentioning the importance of an early referral to a fertility unit facilitate a full discussion of all suitable options for the individual patients.
Fertility and its preservation
The chemotherapy drugs used in the treatment of breast cancer can be damaging to the ovaries, including alkylating agents (e.g, cyclophosphamide), anthracyclines (epirubicin) and taxanes (docetaxel and paclitaxel). The growing follicles of the ovary are very sensitive to these drugs, and as it is these follicles that produce estradiol; the loss of these follicles and hormones is the reason many women will stop having periods during and for a time after chemotherapy, and in some they will not return. In the longer term however, it is the effect of these treatments on the non-growing follicles (called primordial follicles) that matters. All these follicles are formed before a woman is born and can’t be replaced: this makes up what is called the ‘ovarian reserve’. If nearly all these primordial follicles are lost during treatment, the ovary can’t recover and there will be little chance of pregnancy. Hormone therapies will also affect ovarian function, but don’t damage the non-growing follicles, so their effect is only while the woman is taking them. There is little known about whether targeted therapies are damaging to the ovary: in many cases there may again be a temporary disturbance in ovarian function but not permanent damage.
After breast cancer treatment such as chemotherapy stops, follicles surviving within the ovaries should start growing again, periods should resume, and the woman may be able to become pregnant. If a woman’s periods are going to return, this is usually within a year: if they haven’t returned by 2 years it is unlikely that they will return. The chance of there being follicles remaining after treatment is higher in women in their 20’s and 30’s and most of those women will not have permanent loss of ovarian function after treatment for early breast cancer.
Many women may not have started or completed their family when they are diagnosed with breast cancer. This may be an important issue for them that it may impact their treatment decisions. Analysis of women in Scotland has shown that only about 10% of women aged under 40 at diagnosis will have a baby after breast cancer 1. The situation is more complicated when postponing the opportunity for pregnancy with longer term treatment with anti-HER2 drugs or endocrine therapy is proposed, as age is the most important factor in female fertility.
Is having a baby after breast cancer safe?
There is currently no evidence to suggest that having a baby increases the risk of breast cancer returning. Analysis of all women having a baby after breast cancer in Scotland over the last 40 years showed no evidence of an increased risk overall, or specifically in women with hormone receptor positive (HR+) disease, or those who had a baby within 5 years of diagnosis2. Additionally, data from the recent POSITIVE study suggests that stopping endocrine therapy for a suggested period of time to become pregnant is safe3.
Fertility preservation
Trials have investigated whether it is possible to protect female fertility with gonadotropin releasing hormone (GnRH) analogues- such as goserelin, triptorelin- during chemotherapy. Three Randomised Clinical Trials (RCTs), including one in the UK, all showed that administration of a GnRH analogue reduced the risk of premature ovarian insufficiency (POI)- the current term for early ovarian failure– after treatment for breast cancer4. This has led to the widespread use of this approach but importantly, these trials did not show that this improved fertility, and it should not be relied on as a way to preserve fertility.
Fertility preservation is based on oocyte (egg), or embryo cryopreservation undertaken before chemotherapy starts. It is available at all four NHS IVF (in vitro fertilisation) centres in Scotland for women about to have breast cancer treatment that may affect their fertility. To be eligible, the following criteria must be met:
- She must be under the age of 41
- She should not have any children already
- BMI under 35 kg/m2
- She doesn’t need to be in a relationship, although she will need to be when she comes back to use the eggs as NHS Scotland does not currently offer fertility treatment to single women.
It is essential that a woman considering embryo cryostorage recognises that those embryos are the joint property of her and the partner whose sperm was used to create them. If the relationship breaks down, his consent is required for her to use those embryos.
Egg and embryo freezing
In brief, the patient will need approximately two weeks of daily injections to stimulate her ovaries. To avoid delay, these can be started at any stage in the menstrual cycle. The eggs are then collected by passing a needle (attached to an ultrasound probe) through the top of the vagina into each ovary. This is done under sedation. If the patient wishes to use her partner’s sperm to fertilise the eggs and then freeze the resulting embryos, that can also be done but it is essential that she realises that those embryos are then joint property with him. Eggs/embryos can be stored until the woman is 55 years old (if that is what she consents to), but after the first few years there may be storage charges: the duration of free storage is under discussion at present.
Useful resources:
How successful is fertility preservation?
About 1 in 20 frozen eggs can become a baby, and its lower than that in women over 35. As fewer than 10 eggs will be frozen from most women, and sometimes only very few, this means that having fertility preservation cannot be seen as a guarantee that it will result in a baby.
What happens later?
When the patient wishes to conceive, the cryopreserved eggs are warmed, fertilised using the partner’s sperm (or a donor in same-sex couples), and with appropriate estrogen and progesterone treatment an embryo can be replaced in the uterus a few days later. If there are other good quality embryos, these can be re-frozen for later use.
Eligibility criteria for NHS fertility treatment will need to be met again at the time of use of the eggs or embryos, at present, these are:
- Age under 41
- BMI 30 or less
- The couple should have no children together
- Single women are not eligible for NHS fertility treatment.
Referral pathways