Skip to main content
  1. Right Decisions
  2. GGC - Clinical Guidelines
  3. Paediatrics
  4. Back
  5. Emergency Medicine (Paediatric)
  6. Jehovah's Witness management, paediatric patients (644)
Important: please update your RDS app to version 4.7.3 Details with newsletter below.

Please update your RDS app to v4.7.3

We asked you in January to update to v4.7.2.  After the deployment planned for 27th February, this new update will be needed to ensure that you are able to download RDS toolkits even when the RDS website is not available. We will wait until as many users as possible have downloaded the new version before switching off the old system for app downloads and moving entirely to the new approach.

To check your current RDS version, click on the three dots bottom right of the RDS app screen. This takes you to a “More” page where you will see the version number. 

To update to the latest release:

 On iPhones – go to the Apple store, click on your profile icon top right, scroll down to see the apps waiting to be updated and update the RDS app.

On Android phones – these can vary, but try going to the Google Play store, click on your profile icon top right, click on “Manage apps and device”, select and update the RDS app.

Right Decision Service newsletter: February 2025

Welcome to the February 2025 update from the RDS team

1.     Next release of RDS

 

A new release of RDS is planned (subject to outcomes of current testing) for week beginning 24th February. This will deliver:

 

  • Fixes to mitigate the recurring glitches with the RDS admin area and the occasional brief user interface outages which have arisen following implementation of the new distributed technology infrastructure in December 2024.

 

  • Capability to embed content from Google calendar, Google Maps, Daily Motion, Twitter feeds, Microsoft Stream into RDS pages.

 

  • Capability to include simple multiplication in RDS calculators.

 

The release will also incorporate a number of small fixes, including:

  • Exporting of form within Medicines Sick Day Guidance in polypharmacy toolkit
  • Links to redundant content appearing in search in some RDS toolkits
  • Inclusion of accordion headers alongside accordion text in search result snippets.
  • Feedback form on mobile app.
  • Internal links on mobile app version of benzo tapering tool

 

We will let you know when the date and time for the new release are confirmed.

 

2.     New RDS developments

There is now the capability to publish toolkits on the web with left hand side navigation rather than tiles on the homepage. To use this feature, turn on the “Toggle navigation panel” option at the top of the Page settings menu at toolkit homepage level – see below. Please note that publication to downloadable mobile app for this type of navigation is still under development.

The Benzodiazepine tapering tool (https://rightdecisions.scot.nhs.uk/benzotapering) is now available as part of the RDS toolkit for the national benzodiazepine prescribing guidance developed by the Scottish Government Effective Prescribing team. The tool uses this national guidance developed with a wide-ranging multidisciplinary group. This should be used in combination with professional judgement and an understanding of the needs of the individual patient.

3.     Archiving and version control and new RDS Search and Browse interface

Due to the intensive work Tactuum has had to undertake on the new technology infrastructure has pushed back the delivery dates again and some new requirements have come out of the recent user acceptance testing. It now looks likely to be an April release for the search and browse interface. The archiving and version control functionality may be released earlier. We’ll keep you posted.

4.     Statistics

At the end of January, Olivia completed the generation of the latest set of usage statistics for all RDS toolkits. If you would like a copy of the stats for your toolkit, please contact Olivia.graham@nhs.scot .

 

5.     Review of content past its review date

We have now generated reports of all RDS toolkit content that has exceeded its review date by 6 months or more. We will be in touch later this month with toolkit owners and editors to agree the plan for updating or withdrawing out of date content.

 

6.     Toolkits in development

Some important toolkits in development by the RDS team include:

  • National CVD prevention pathways – due for release end of March 2025.
  • National respiratory pathways, optimal cancer diagnostic pathways and cancer prehabilitation pathways from the Centre for Sustainable Delivery. We will shortly start work on the national cancer referral pathways, first version due for release via RDS around end of June 2025.
  • HIS Quality of Care Review toolkit – currently in final stages of quality assurance.

 

The RDS team and other information scientists in HIS have also been producing evidence summaries for the Scottish Government Realistic Medicine team, to inform development of national guidance around Procedures of Limited Clinical Value. This guidance will in due course be translated into an RDS toolkit.

 

7. Training sessions for new editors (also serve as refresher sessions for existing editors) will take place on the following dates:

  • Friday 28th February 12-1 pm
  • Tuesday 11th March 4-5 pm

 

To book a place, please contact Olivia.graham@nhs.scot, providing your name, organisation, job role, and level of experience with RDS editing (none, a little, moderate, extensive.)

 

To invite colleagues to sign up to receive this newsletter, please signpost them to the registration form  - also available in End-user and Provider sections of the RDS Learning and Support area.   If you have any questions about the content of this newsletter, please contact his.decisionsupport@nhs.scot  If you would prefer not to receive future newsletters, please email Olivia.graham@nhs.scot and ask to be removed from the circulation list.

With kind regards

 

Right Decision Service team

Healthcare Improvement Scotland

 

 

Jehovah's Witness management, paediatric patients (644)

Warning

Objectives

This guideline aims to summarise the considerations of managing a paediatric patient for whom they themselves, or their carer, objects to the use of blood products. It does not aim to provide comprehensive background or discussion. Please refer to existing guidelines including NHS GGC, Association of Anaesthetists, RCS for more detailed information.

Introduction

It is estimated that 140,000 Jehovah’s Witnesses (JW) currently reside in the UK, with 10,000 in Scotland1,2. Jehovah’s Witnesses typically refuse the allogenic transfusion of whole blood and primary blood components. Any non-consensual transfusion would be considered a gross physical violation. Some non-JW patients may also refuse blood and their decision should be similarly respected. The indication for and medical consequence of not receiving blood products should be discussed with each patient and their specific situation.

Jehovah’s Witnesses believe that were a member of their church to ‘wilfully and unrepentantly’ accept a blood transfusion then they will be considered to have left the faith. However, they also report that there is ‘no rejection of those transfused against their will, or in error, or of a child where that action has been taken by clinicians in an effort to preserve health and life’3.

Contacts

Additional resources available to provide pastoral and liaison support throughout the UK for elective and emergency cases are available at: 

Hospital Information Desk,
Great Britain and Ireland headquarters:

24 hour service: 020 8371 3415
Email: hid.gb@jw.org.
Medical resource: www.jw.org/en/medical-library

Glasgow Local Contacts:

Paul Cura - 07305438774pcura@jw-hlc.org.uk

Peter Warden - 07974578897; pwarden@jw-hlc.org.uk

Anthony Chali - 07877312028; achali@jw-hlc.org.uk

David Butler - 07722475834; dbutler@jw-hlc.org

Ethical considerations

Capacity 

In Scotland, parents cannot give consent at all for young people over the age of 16. If they lack capacity, they should be treated under the guidance laid out in the Adults with Incapacity (Scotland) Act 20003.

A child under the age of 16 can consent to a procedure if they are deemed by a medical practitioner as capable of understanding the nature and consequences of the procedure [Section 2(4) of the Age of Legal Capacity (Scotland) Act 1991]3. As they are considered to have capacity and be competent then they have the right to refuse treatment and neither the parents nor the court can override it in theory, though this has not be definitively tested in the courts3.

Consent

In addition to capacity, consent requires the decision maker to be fully informed of the risks, benefits and alternatives of the treatment, and for this information to be comprehended. In addition, it is essential that the decision is free from coercion. 

Ideally, the discussion regarding administration of blood products should be made remote to theatres with adequate time and privacy. As much as it should be clear that a child with capacity has made the decision of their own reasoning and values, it is similarly important that the medical professional also does not aim to impose undue influence on the decision which is not in keeping with the patient’s own wishes and values.

Emergency

In an emergency blood products can be administered in a life-sustaining situation or to prevent lasting disability without patient or parental consent. Two consultants should agree and document the clinical urgency for blood administration2. Legal permission for treatment in the face of parental refusal should be sought at the earliest available opportunity.

Doctor’s Right to Refuse 

Should a medical professional feel they cannot work under the proposed constraints associated with refusal to use blood products, a referral to another appropriately skilled clinical or team should be made and recorded in the notes and an appropriate explanation be given to the family3.

Legal considerations

Specific Issue Order

A Specific Issue Order, under Section 8 of the Children’s Act 1989, can be made when a child is under 182, with the court acting with the welfare of the child being paramount. The court will make an order, in this situation regarding blood transfusions for the child, superseding parental rights only surrounding this issue. It does not take away any other existing parental rights, and the parents should still be informed of ongoing management plans. Applications should always be made where time permits.

Algorithm

Algorithm for Refusal of Blood Products in a Paediatric Patient

Perioperative management

Preoperative

Consent for Blood Components and Procedures

The four primary blood components; red cells, white cells, platelets and FFP are most typically refused. Pre-deposited autologous blood is also generally not acceptable.

The acceptance of primary blood product derivatives is a matter of personal choice. The use of these products should be discussed on an individual basis. Similarly with procedures involving the use of their own blood, including:

  • intraoperative or postoperative cell salvage
  • Acute normovolaemic haemodilution
  • Haemodialysis or haemofiltration - Cardiopulmonary bypass

Optimisation

Schedule early attendance at pre-operative clinics with baseline Hb measurement. Consider EPO/Iron infusions if low Hb. Investigate any clotting or bleeding issues. Withhold anticoagulants and anti-platelet agents where possible.

Multi-disciplinary discussion and planning is imperative.

Intraoperative

All effort should be made to avoid the use of blood products where refused. Consider techniques including:

  • Minimise blood sampling
  • Maintain normothermia
  • Tranexamic acid
  • Acute normovolaemic haemodilution if patient suitable

Postoperative

Optimise oxygen consumption and delivery. Repeated blood sampling should only occur when necessary. Monitor post-operative blood loss closely, with early recognition and prompt intervention required.

Editorial Information

Last reviewed: 23/12/2022

Next review date: 31/01/2026

Author(s): Ros Lawson, Monique McLeod & Barry Crockett.

Version: 2

Approved By: Paediatric & Neonatal Clinical Risk & Effectiveness Committee

References
  1. Watson, T., Morrsion, A. “Protocol for Patients who Refuse Blood." NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde. June 2016. 
  2. Caring for patients who refuse blood: A Guide to Good Practice for the Surgical Management of Jehovah’s Witnesses and Other Patients Who Decline Transfusion.” Royal College of Surgeons of England Professional and Clinical Standards. Nov 2016.
  3. Klein A., Bailey, C.R. et al. “Anaesthesia and peri-operative care for Jehovah’s Witnesses and patients who refuse blood”. AAGBI Guidelines, 2nd ed. 2005.