Warning

Background

Rationale for de-labelling penicillin allergies

  • 10% of hospital inpatients have a documented allergy to penicillin.  
  • 90% of these are not truly penicillin allergic.
  • Using non beta-lactam* based antibiotics can be associated with harm including worse outcomes from the infection being managed and additional toxicity from the antibiotics used. 
  • De-labelling allows you to use penicillin antibiotics for the current infection (and future infections).  
  • Further information in the format of FAQs is available here.

Safety of de-labelling

  • Many patients who report an allergy actually have an intolerance or side effect and can be safely de-labelled without further assessment. 
  • The penFAST tool has been validated in identifying low risk penicillin allergy patients who are suitable for de-labelling. 
  • Oral penicillin challenge has been shown to be equally safe and effective as skin testing in low risk patients. 
  • Delayed reactions post challenge can occur although these are uncommon and generally mild.

Who can assess a penicillin allergy?

  • A penicillin allergy history and penFAST score can be undertaken by all clinical staff.
  • Direct de-labelling can be undertaken by all prescribers using the guidance below. 
  • Oral penicillin challenge should only be undertaken by prescribers after consulting with the senior clinician responsible for the patient.

What settings can the de-labelling protocol be used in?

  • This protocol can be used in both outpatient and inpatient secondary care settings where resuscitation equipment, and staff trained in its use are available. This includes hospital wards, outpatient departments, critical care and emergency departments.
* A summary of which antibiotics are in the beta-lactam group can be found in the "Antimicrobial prescribing for patients with penicillin allergy" section at the bottom of this page

Step 1: Taking a penicillin allergy history

Antibiotic allergy history

  • What antibiotic was the patient given? 
    • Was it an injection or a tablet? 
  • When (was it >5 years ago)? 
  • What happened (GI upset, facial swelling, anaphylaxis etc.)?  
  • Where (community, GP practice, hospital) 
  • Onset after taking antibiotic (Minutes, hours, weeks) 
  • Treatment required (in particular, was adrenaline given)? 
  • Has a Severe Cutaneous Adverse Reaction (SCAR) occurred? These include: 
    • Steven-Johnson Syndrome (SJS)/Toxic Epidermal Necrolysis (TEN) 
    • Drug Reaction with Eosinophilia & Systemic Symptoms (DRESS) 
    • Acute Generalised Exanthematous Pustulosis (AGEP) 

 

Features in history suggestive of different reactions: 

Intolerance/side effects  Type 1 Hypersensitivity (usual onset <1 hour)  Severe Cutaneous Adverse Reaction (SCAR) 
  • Minor gastrointestinal upset 
  • Nausea  
  • Headache  
  • Fatigue 
  • Isolated itch with no rash 
  • Collapse 
  • Facial/throat swelling (angiooedema) 
  • Breathing difficulties 
  • Urticarial rash 
  • Rash with blistering 
  • Oral or Genital ulceration or blistering 
  • Rash associated with a severe systemic illness requiring admission to hospital 

 

Other sources of information

Often patients are uncertain of the nature of the reaction, in which case consider these sources of information 

  • GP: Phone to ask: 
    • Are there are details in the primary care record? 
    • Has the patient received other penicillins (amoxicillin/flucloxacillin/co-amoxiclav) since the documented reaction? 
  • TRAK/HEPMA: Has the patient received other penicillins since the documented reaction? Check previous admissions notes/letters. 
  • Collateral history from relatives 

Step 2: Assess suitability for de-labelling

Step 2.1: Assess suitability for direct de-labelling 

History Category Next Step

Symptoms consistent with intolerance only (see table in Step 1) 

OR 

Family history of penicillin allergy, but no personal history of penicillin allergy 

OR 

History of tolerating penicillin antibiotic after initial reaction

Can be directly de-labelled

Oral challenge not required

 

Go to Step 4 

Some patients may continue avoiding penicillin if they do not have the reassurance of a negative allergy test. In these circumstances, an oral challenge can be considered: go to Step 3

History suggestive of true penicillin allergy 

OR 

Uncertain nature of reaction 

May be suitable for oral penicillin challenge  Go to Step 2.2 and calculate penFAST score

 

Step 2.2 Calculate penFAST score

Penicillin allergy reported   
Five years or less since reaction  2 points 

Anaphylaxis or angioedema 

OR 

Severe cutaneous adverse reaction (SCAR) 

2 points 
Treatment required for reaction  1 point 

 

Step 2.3: Interpretation of penFAST score 

penFAST score Risk of true hypersensitivity/allergy Recommendation
0 <1%

Suitable for oral penicillin challenge (unless SCAR) 

Go to Step 3 

1-2 5%
3 20% Unsuitable for oral penicillin challenge, go to Step 5 
4-5 50%

 

Step 3: Oral penicillin challenge protocol

This protocol must only be used for patients assessed as suitable for oral penicillin challenge by following Steps 1&2 above. 

 

Step 3.1: Pre-challenge checks 

  1. Ensure discussion with senior clinician responsible for patient before proceeding. 
  2. Ensure adequate medical staff available with training in the management of anaphylaxis. Resuscitation equipment must be available nearby. Medical staff should remain on-site for the first 20 minutes minimum. 
  3. Ensure nursing staff available to undertaken required monitoring.
  4. Patients taking antihistamines should temporarily stop these for 24 hours prior to challenge, where safe to do so. 
  5. Inform the patient of the risks/benefits/alternatives of de-labelling which are outlined in the "Background" section, and provide Patient Information Leaflet, found here.
    • Inform the patient to seek medical attention if they develop symptoms of a delayed reaction. If they develop symptoms of a SCAR they should seek urgent review (see Step 1 for details). 
  6. Document patient consent on TRAK. If written consent is preferred, the SAPG consent form can be used, found here.

 

Step 3.2: Exclusion criteria 

  1. Clinically unstable or deteriorating patients (based on treating senior clinician’s judgement) 
  2. Pregnant
  3. <18 years old 
  4. Patients receiving omalizumab (may mask reaction to challenge)
  5. Uncontrolled asthma/COPD (complicates management of potential anaphylaxis)
  6. Antihistamine use in past 24 hours (may mask reaction to challenge)
  7. Previous urticaria, anaphylaxis or SCAR from a beta-lactam antimicrobial

If there are exclusion criteria present go to Step 5 and consider de-labelling at a future date if exclusion criteria no longer applicable. If uncertain, consider discussion with infection specialist. 

 

Step 3.3: Oral challenge protocol 

Printable checklists available here for clinicians and nursing staff.

  1. Measure observations at 0 minutes. 
  2. Administer oral penicillin challenge.
    1. Prescribe Amoxicillin 500mg oral on HEPMA (Flucloxacillin 500mg is an alternative, ideally use the antibiotic the reaction was reported to. If uncertain, use amoxicillin).
    2. Alternately prescribe on paper kardex if in non-HEPMA area.
  3. Re-check observations at 20, 40, 60 minutes. 
  4. Assess outcome at 120 minutes (see table below).

 

Step 3.4: Assessment of outcome

Outcome Interpretation Next Steps

No reaction

OR

Symptoms consistent with side effect/intolerance (see table in Step 1)

De-labelling successful, not penicillin allergic  Go to Step 4 
Uncertain if symptoms/signs consistent with hypersensitivity reaction  Uncertain  Discuss with infection specialist (Medical Microbiology or Infectious Diseases)

Symptoms or signs consistent with hypersensitivity reaction, e.g.: 

  • Rash +/- itch 
  • Facial swelling 
  • Breathing difficulties 
  • Hypotension 
(see table in Step 1 for more details)

Allergy confirmed 

Patients who experience allergic symptoms during a challenge should be assessed and managed according to the SAPG guidelines on management of allergic symptoms

Patients experiencing anaphylaxis should be treated without delay according to the ALS protocol

Consider taking a tryptase level

Go to Step 5 

 

Step 4: De-labelling successful

Clearly document the challenge has taken place and the outcome, by following the steps below: 

  1. Document in TRAK patient notes, using “\penicillindelabelled” 
  2. Update TRAK & HEPMA allergies field, removing the allergy label and adding the comment: 
    • “Successfully de-labelled DD/MM/YYYY following oral challenge: Patient is NOT penicillin-allergic" 
  3. Inform patient and provide patient information leaflet here.
  4. Inform patient’s GP by adding to immediate discharge letter/correspondence and sending standard letter via email to the GP practice clinical email address [accessable via intranet only]. 

 

Clear documentation is important as patients who have been successfully de-labelled are commonly “re-labelled” on a subsequent admission leading to unnecessary avoidance of penicillin based antibiotics, or unnecessary re-assessment of allergy. 

Step 5: De-labelling unsuccessful or not suitable

If de-labelling was not deemed safe/suitable:

Clearly document the nature of the allergy and the reason de-labelling is not safe/suitable, by following the steps below: 

  1. Document in patient notes, in particular the reason they are not suitable for de-labelling, using "\penicillinallergy"
  2. Update TRAK & HEPMA allergies field, maintaining the allergy label and adding the comment: 
    • “Not suitable for allergy de-labelling on DD/MM/YYYY due to: XXXX" 
  3. Inform patient and provide patient information leaflet here
  4. Inform the patient’s GP and ask them to ensure the patient's ECS is updated with nature of allergy: 
    • Include nature of allergy in discharge letter/correspondence 
    • Consider sending a specific letter or email to the GP practice as appropriate 

Review the "Antimicrobial prescribing for patients with penicillin allergy" section for further advice.

If de-labelling was attempted and allergy confirmed:

Clearly document the challenge has taken place and the outcome, by following the steps below: 

  1. Document in patient notes, using “\penicillinallergy” 
  2. Update TRAK & HEPMA allergies field, maintaining the allergy label and adding the comment: 
    • “Allergy to XXXX confirmed DD/MM/YYYY following oral challenge: symptoms/signs XXXX" 
  3. Inform patient and provide patient information leaflet here. 
  4. Inform the patient’s GP and ask them to ensure ECS is updated with nature of allergy: 
    • Include nature of allergy in discharge letter/correspondence 
    • Consider sending a specific letter or email to the GP practice as appropriate

Review the "Antimicrobial prescribing for patients with penicillin allergy" section for further advice.

 

Clear documentation is important to avoid uncertainty around the nature of a patient's allergy in the future.

Antimicrobial prescribing for patients with penicillin allergy

Within each section of the Body Systems guidelines, there will be antimicrobial treatment options suggested for patients with penicillin allergy.

 

Beta-lactam group Examples of antimicrobials used in NHS Lothian
Penicillins Benzylpenicillin (IV), phenoxymethylpenicillin (oral), Amoxicillin, Flucloxacillin, Piperacillin-Tazobactam (Tazocin), Temocillin, Pivmecillinam
Cephalosporins Ceftriaxone, Ceftazidime, Cefuroxime, Cephalexin, Cefazolin
Carbapenems Meropenem, Ertapenem
Monobactams Aztreonam

 

Key points:

  1. Penicillins, cephalosporins and carbapenems share a beta-lactam ring structure. However hypersensitivity is related to the side chains that differ significantly between different classes of beta-lactam antimicrobials.
  2. Patients with a penicillin allergy should not receive other penicillin antibiotics, as they share similar side chains, and have similar metabolites which can lead to cross-reactivity.
  3. The risk of cross-reactivity between a penicillin allergy and a cephalosporin is estimated at <1%, except for cephalexin as it shares a side chain with the penicillins.
  4. Cephalosporins (apart from cephalexin) can be used in patients with a non-severe penicillin allergy (e.g. delayed onset reaction such as rash without SCAR).
  5. Carbapenems can generally be safely used in patients with penicillin allergy regardless of severity, after discussion with an infection specialist.
  6. Aztreonam can safely be used in most patients with penicillin allergy (noting the potential for cross-reactivity with certain cephalosporin allergies including cefuroxime and ceftazidime, see chart below)
  7. Patients with severe penicillin allergy (e.g. features suggestive Type 1 Hypersensivity reaction or SCAR (see Table in Step 1)) should be discussed with an Infection Specialist if there is not a clear recommendation for empirical treatment in the relevant Body Systems section.

 

Cross-reactivity table

Further information on side-chain homology between different beta-lactam antimicrobials can be found in the chart below. This does not replace discussion with an Infection Specialist.

Click on the image to enlarge

chart showing varous beta-lactam antibiotics and the risk of cross-reactivity related to side chain homology.
Source: Dutch Working Party on Antibiotic Policy 2023 Guidelines

References

These guidelines were written following a stakeholder meeting and are based on the following guidelines and papers:

  • Scottish Antimicrobial Prescribing Group, Penicillin Allergy Delabelling. https://www.sapg.scot/guidance-qi-tools/quality-improvement-tools/penicillin-allergy-de-labelling/ (accessed Aug 29 2024).
  • The Dutch Working Party on Antibiotic Policy (SWAB) guideline for the approach to suspected Antibiotic Allergy https://swab.nl/en/exec/file/download/192 (accessed Aug 29 2024)
  • Standards of Care Committee of the British Society for Allergy and Clinical Immunology. Management of allergy to penicillins and other beta-lactams. Clin Exp Allergy 2015 doi:10.1111/cea.12468
  • BSACI guideline for the set-up of penicillin allergy de-labelling services by non-allergists working in a hospital setting. Clin Exp Allergy. 2022. doi:10.1111/cea.14217 
  • Oral challenge vs routine care to assess low-risk penicillin allergy in critically ill hospital patients (ORACLE): a pilot safety and feasibility randomised controlled trial. Intensive Care Med 2024. doi.org/10.1007/s00134-024-07448-x
  • A multicentre observational study to investigate feasibility of a direct oral penicillin challenge in de-labelling ‘low risk’ patients with penicillin allergy by non-allergy healthcare professionals (SPACE study): Implications for healthcare systems. Journal of Infection 2024.  doi.org/10.1016/j.jinf.2024.01.015 
  • Efficacy of a Clinical Decision Rule to Enable Direct Oral Challenge in Patients With Low-Risk Penicillin Allergy. The PALACE Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA Intern Med 2023. doi:10.1001/jamainternmed.2023.2986
  • Reaction Risk to Direct Penicillin Challenges. A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. JAMA Intern Med 2024. doi:10.1001/jamainternmed.2024.4606

Editorial Information

Last reviewed: 07/07/2025

Next review date: 11/07/2028

Author(s): Dr Callum Mutch, Dr Jessica Smith, Dr Florence McLean, Dr Rebecca Sutherland, Dr Simon Dewar.

Version: 2.0

Approved By: Antimicrobial Management Committee

Reviewer name(s): loth.antimicrobialstewardship@nhs.scot.